New tools to aid in recycling flat-screen monitors, TVs

Millions of flat-screen monitors and television sets will soon become obsolete, posing environmental hazards, and Purdue University researchers are developing tools to help industry efficiently recycle the products.

Purdue University researchers are developing tools to help industry efficiently recycle millions of flat-screen monitors and television sets expected to become obsolete soon. The monitors contain hazardous - as well as valuable - materials. In this picture, the lines and dots in a drive circuit contain indium, which sells for about $600 per kilogram. (Purdue University image/Gamini Mendis) Download Photo
Purdue University researchers are developing tools to help industry efficiently recycle millions of flat-screen monitors and television sets expected to become obsolete soon. The monitors contain hazardous - as well as valuable - materials. In this picture, the lines and dots in a drive circuit contain indium, which sells for about $600 per kilogram. (Purdue University image/Gamini Mendis) Download Photo

Liquid crystal displays manufactured before 2009 use cold cathode fluorescent lamps, or CCFLs, to backlight the display. The CCFL displays contain mercury, making them hazardous to dispose of or incinerate.

"Over the next few years, it is expected that hundreds of millions of CCFL-backlighted LCDs will retire each year," said Fu Zhao, an assistant professor in the School of Mechanical Engineering and Division of Environmental and Ecological Engineering. "Without proper treatment, these used LCDs could lead to serious damage to the environment."

Purdue researchers are working to aid industry in recycling the displays through a new project funded by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's People, Prosperity and the Planet - or P3 - program.

"We will produce equipment and tools specifically designed to disassemble LCDs with acceptable labor cost while recovering high-value components and reducing environmental hazards," Zhao said.

He is leading the project with Carol Handwerker, Reinhardt Schuhmann Jr. Professor of Materials Engineering.

Electronic products contain hazardous chemicals such as heavy metals and brominated flame retardants. The materials can leach out of landfills into groundwater and streams or be converted into "super toxicants" including dioxin while being incinerated.

More than 3 million tons of e-waste were generated in 2007 in the United States, with 13.6 percent collected for recycling and 86.4 percent going to landfills and incinerators. Environmental concerns have led 25 states to pass laws mandating e-waste recycling.

"Because many states have laws prohibiting disposal of electronic wastes in landfills, used LCDs are likely to be incinerated in large-scale capital-intensive facilities or shipped to developing countries," Zhao said. "Neither scenario is good from a sustainability perspective. Incineration is expensive, and materials and energy are wasted. Exporting e-wastes to developing countries damages local environments, harms people's health and is against environmental justice."

LCD hardware typically has a lifespan of 10 to 20 years.

"However, due to rapid technology advances, LCD monitors and TVs are becoming obsolete much faster," Zhao said. "The life cycle for products is speeding up, in part because people want the latest products."

Surveys of e-waste collectors and recyclers indicate that LCD monitors and TVs manufactured four to five years ago have started showing up in waste streams. The high cost of e-waste recycling in the United States and Europe has posed challenges in managing the high-tech trash, but new tools to efficiently disassemble LCD panels could make recycling profitable, he said.

"Recycling hundreds of millions of LCDs will create new job opportunities," Zhao said.

The new equipment and tools will be tested by e-waste recyclers, and field data will be collected. The tools will be used to more easily remove a monitor's housing and detach circuit boards and metal frames, then separate polarizing filters, glass, liquid crystals, and the mercury-containing backlight unit.

"A unique feature is that these new tools allow quick access, separation, and recovery of high value parts and toxic sub-assemblies," Zhao said.

An LCD monitor includes the front frame, back cover, metal frame, circuit boards, the liquid crystal subassembly with a driver circuit and the backlight unit. Electrode patterns are made of a layer of indium tin oxide, or ITO. The backlight unit includes a frame, fluorescent tubes, a prism, a "diffuser," a reflector, and a protective layer. The liquid crystal subassembly's drive circuit has a gold coating.

"The gold price is currently higher than $50 per gram, and the drive circuit may contain 1-2 grams of gold," Zhao said.

In the past several years, increasing demands from LCD and thin-film solar cell manufacturing have led to the price of indium running from less than $100 per kilogram in 2003 to more than $600 per kilogram in 2011.

"Therefore, recovering the ITO-coated glass makes business sense," Zhao said.

Because fluorescent tubes in the backlight unit contain mercury, the unit must be removed carefully and then sent for proper disposal. To access the backlight unit, the front frame has to be removed first.

"Although screw drivers can be used to remove the front frame, this is not preferred due to potential risks of breaking the backlight unit, which results in mercury release," Zhao said. "To minimize the probability of breaking the tubes, a case-opening tool will first be developed."

A different tool will be developed to remove the back cover from the metal frame.

In 2010, LCD TVs using light emitting diodes as backlights gained popularity. The LED-backlighted LCDs contain no toxic substances and consume 20 percent to 30 percent less electricity than the CCFL technology.

"Although the LED monitors don't contain mercury, they are still e-waste and will need to be recycled," Zhao said. "At the same time, the LED-backlighted monitors contain valuable materials that will be cost-effective to recover."

Two graduate students and five undergraduate students from mechanical engineering, materials engineering and environmental and ecological engineering are working on the project. The team is expected to showcase their prototype at the National Sustainable Design Expo next April on the National Mall in Washington, D.C.

Writer: Emil Venere,  765-494-4709, venere@purdue.edu

Source: Fu Zhao,  765-494-6637, fzhao@purdue.edu

Comments

So in various cases... this is salvaging existing components for re-using.
Sensible... but not really what I would call in line with what we can actually do.

In the late 19th century we perfected recycling to the point where we can recycle heavy metals.
We had the ability since then to disassemble existing matter into base elements and reconstitute it into a different form of matter, or alternative energy sources.

And of course, this method is simply conforming to the business model of the current socio-economic system.

I'm appalled.

One other thing I noticed.

"However, due to rapid technology advances, LCD monitors and TVs are becoming obsolete much faster," Zhao said. "The life cycle for products is speeding up, in part because people want the latest products."".

I would hope that people understand its not so much 'due to rapid technology advances...', but rather because already invented technologies from a long while back have just began to lower in price where manufacturers can incorporate them into consumer grade technology for a low cost.
Other than that, even the technologies coming to the market are basically sorely lacking in what can be done.
Creating displays/computers/tools/hardware/technology in general with superior synthetic materials that can be produced in abundance but in line with our latest scientific knowledge would effectively render everything and anything coming out in Capitalism over the next decade or much more... utterly obsolete.

Besides, CCFL's could be used as raw matter for creation of superior synthetic materials that can be used for technology (mercury as well).

For the immediate monetary system, since current displays are still on LED's, then the logical thing to do would be to convert CCFL's backlit screens into LED's (its possible - requires a converter for the older connectors, but those already existed for some time - LCDparts website sells such LED kits for conversion along with instructions - and its something I considered doing on my laptop whose backlight went out).

Anyway... the point I'm trying to make is that having 'the latest and the greatest' in capitalism or market based economy in general is always behind on our latest scientific knowledge and utterly obsolete by comparison - but, it also doesn't have to produce enormous waste like it does now.
Instead, we can simply harvest existing hardware for its resources/raw materials and convert it into what is considered 'newest'.
For more fully integrated technologies such as smartphones, tablets, etc... same idea... save your data on a computer, wipe the phone, have it be disassembled into base elements which can then be used to create 'the newest'.
Simple.
You might end up with minimal waste that can also be used for something else (I mean, we practically do have the ability to recycle almost anything or create something usable for it).